Green fuels kill biodiversity. EU fails to address deforestation from palm and soy biofuels in update to green fuels law.

In the final trilogue negotiations on the EU’s Renewable Energy Directive (RED), the EU drastically increased its target for renewables in transport from 14% to 29% (1).
Negotiators also included an obligation on EU states to include electricity in their energy quotas for transport. However, a focus on quantity over quality will see a big role of damaging biofuels in Europe’s future energy mix.
The Council and Commission’s failure to support a rapid phase out of soy and palm oil biofuels is a disaster for forests, says T&E.

Despite a push from the biofuels lobby to increase the role of crop-based biofuels, the cap will remain at 2020 levels and their use remains optional for member states. However, the Commission and Council rejected the EU Parliament’s proposal to immediately phase out palm and soy biofuels, which are heavily linked to the clearance of forests and conversion of peatlands.

On soy, the EU Commission is now tasked with reviewing the delegated act on high deforestation risk biofuels this year. Similarly, on palm, instead of an immediate phase-out, the Commission will assess the possibility of accelerating its removal from EU renewable energy targets.

Barbara Smailagic, Fuels Policy Officer at T&E, said: “The EU had a chance today to stand up for forests by ending the use of palm and soy biofuels now. It has failed. But with a review still to come this year, the Commission has a chance to put this right. Every day it delays the removal of palm and soy biofuels from its green fuels law, hundreds of football pitches worth of forest are lost.”

Renewable electricity
Currently most EU states simply require oil companies to blend so-called renewable liquids like ethanol or biodiesel to meet renewable energy targets. The update to the RED deal now includes an obligation on EU states to include electricity in their energy quotas for transport. This important change alters the balance of a law which previously only favoured biofuels and will mean that the oil industry is now going to have to finance renewable electricity in transport, says T&E.

Geert Decock, Electricity & Energy Manager at T&E, said: “Following the revision of the RED, oil companies can comply by supplying renewable electricity. While this won’t grab the headlines, this represents a sea change in Europe’s fuel politics. Instead of a green fuels law focused on blending for a combustion engine age, we now have a green fuels law that reflects the future of electric mobility.”

RFNBOs and advanced biofuels
Decision makers agreed on a combined sub-target of 5.5% for advanced biofuels and hydrogen and e-fuels – so-called Renewable Fuels of Non-Biological Origin (RFNBOs). A 1% binding target for RFNBOs is a major innovation for supplying more sustainable fuels to the transport sector, especially in helping to decarbonise aviation and shipping. However, the other 4.5% could be completely covered by advanced biofuels, which would drive up demand for unsustainable feedstocks like forestry residues (tree tops, branches, etc.) and manure from industrial livestock farming.

Transport & Environment‘s (T&E) vision is a zero-emission mobility system that is affordable and has minimal impacts on our health, climate and environment.
Since we were created 30 years ago, T&E has shaped some of Europe’s most important environmental laws. We got the EU to set the world’s most ambitious CO2 standards for cars and trucks but also helped uncover the dieselgate scandal; we campaigned successfully to end palm oil diesel; secured a global ban on dirty shipping fuels and the creation of the world’s biggest carbon market for aviation – just to name a few.
Credibility is our key asset. We are a non-profit organisation and politically independent. We combine the power of robust, science-based evidence and a deep understanding of transport with memorable communications and impactful advocacy.
Our staff in Brussels, Rome, Madrid, Berlin, Warsaw and London collaborate with our 63 national member and supporter organisations in 24 countries across Europe. All together our members and supporters represent more than 3.5 million people.
We coordinate the International Coalition for Sustainable Aviation (ICSA), which has observer status at the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO) and are members of the Clean Shipping Coalition (CSC), which has observer status at the International Maritime Organisation (IMO).
We hold a seat on the board of ECOS, and are members of the Green 10 group of European environmental NGOs, Agora Verkehrswende, the Platform for Electromobility, the Coalition for Energy Savings, the Renewable Grids Initiative and the Electrification Alliance.